Let’s start with a fun challenge. In the image above, two women are sitting on a tree branch—each with a saw in hand. One is cutting the branch she’s sitting on (Girl A), while the other is sawing closer to the tree trunk (Girl B).
The question is: Who is more stupid?
Take a second to really look. Your answer might say more about your logic than you think.
Why Most People Get This Puzzle Wrong
This riddle has gone viral because it tricks your instincts. Most people take one quick glance and point to Girl A. Why? Because she’s clearly cutting off the branch she’s sitting on. It seems like a clear case of self-sabotage.
But here’s where things get sneaky. Many puzzle-solvers fall into the trap of jumping to conclusions. They react to the most dramatic image (like Girl A’s fearful face) instead of stepping back and thinking logically.
That’s the trick with this kind of visual riddle: your emotions can cloud your reasoning. And that’s exactly why it’s such a brilliant little test.
Let’s Solve It Together, Step by Step
Let’s break it down carefully and look at every detail. Don’t rush—logic is about clarity, not speed.
Step 1: Analyze Girl A
She’s sitting on the outer edge of the branch, sawing between herself and the tree. If she finishes cutting, she’s going to fall. That’s pretty straightforward. She clearly hasn’t thought things through.
But let’s move on.
Video : guess your answers
Step 2: Take a Closer Look at Girl B
Girl B is sitting closer to the trunk. She’s sawing the branch behind her, in the direction of Girl A. That might seem safer at first, right?
Wrong.
Look again. She’s actually cutting the only piece of the branch that connects her to the trunk. Once she finishes, she’ll fall too—just like Girl A.
Step 3: Compare the Two Mistakes
Both girls are going to fall. But here’s the real difference:
- Girl A’s action is more obvious. She seems unaware that cutting the branch will lead to a fall.
- Girl B’s action is more deceptive—she’s cutting off her connection to the tree while looking angry and determined. She looks like she thinks she’s right.
And that’s the twist: being confidently wrong is often worse than being clueless.
So the answer?
Girl B is more stupid.
She thinks she’s smart and in control, but she’s making the same mistake—if not a worse one—than Girl A. At least Girl A looks hesitant. Girl B, on the other hand, seems determined to fall with pride.
What This Puzzle Teaches Us
This riddle is more than a quick laugh. It reveals how we think under pressure and how often we trust our gut instead of applying logic.
It shows us that:
- Quick answers aren’t always right
- Confidence doesn’t equal correctness
- Looking deeper changes your understanding
It also reminds us that we sometimes judge situations based on expressions, emotions, or drama—when we should really be looking at consequences.
Video : Even the Smartest Professor Can’t Solve All 17 Riddles
So, What’s Your Answer?
Now that you’ve read the logic behind the puzzle, do you still think Girl A is the more foolish one? Or are you seeing it differently now?
Let us know in the comments. And better yet—share this with your friends and see what they choose. It’s always fun to see who’s the fast thinker, who’s the overthinker, and who catches the trick.
Keep Testing Your Brain
If you enjoyed this puzzle, you’re going to love diving into more like it. These kinds of riddles aren’t just fun—they’re little mental workouts. They improve your observation, logic, and decision-making skills.
Next time you come across a brain teaser, slow down and look at the fine print. Because sometimes, the smartest move isn’t about being quick—it’s about being clear.
Ready for another challenge? Keep exploring, keep questioning, and most of all—keep having fun while you sharpen your brain.
