Have you ever come across a riddle that seems simple at first but makes you stop and think twice? Here’s one that will do just that:
“If I have 4 eggs,
A thief gives me 3,
The rooster on my farm lays 5 eggs,
How many eggs do I have?”
At first glance, this riddle may seem straightforward. After all, how hard can it be to count the eggs? But don’t be too quick to jump to an answer just yet! There are some trick elements in this riddle that might cause you to make a mistake if you’re not paying attention to the details. Ready to give it a shot?

Let’s Break Down the Riddle and Test Your Logic
1. “If I have 4 eggs” – A Hypothetical Situation
The first part of the riddle starts with “If I have 4 eggs.” The use of the word “if” is an important clue. This is a hypothetical situation, not a statement of fact. It’s important to realize that the riddle begins by imagining a scenario that might not be true. So, technically, you don’t actually have 4 eggs to begin with.
Common Mistake:
Some people may get confused by this phrasing and immediately assume they start with 4 eggs, which would affect their final calculation. But remember, “if” is suggesting a hypothetical scenario, so we ignore this part when counting the eggs you truly have.
2. “A thief gives me 3” – A Slightly Suspicious Gift
Next, the riddle tells you that a thief gives you 3 eggs. Now, it’s a bit odd that a thief would give you eggs instead of taking them, but let’s go along with the riddle’s quirky logic. Here, you definitely have 3 eggs now, thanks to the thief’s generous (and suspicious) gesture.
Common Mistake:
It’s easy to get distracted by the fact that a thief is involved and focus on the idea of stolen goods. But in this case, we only care about the fact that the thief gave you 3 eggs. So, don’t overthink it!
Video : How many eggs are there?
3. “The rooster on my farm lays 5 eggs” – The Trickiest Part
This is the part of the riddle where most people stumble. The key detail is that the riddle mentions a rooster laying 5 eggs. Now, if you know anything about animals, you’ll quickly realize that roosters (male chickens) cannot lay eggs. Only hens (female chickens) lay eggs.
This is a deliberate trick in the riddle designed to throw you off. Since the rooster can’t lay eggs, this part of the riddle adds no eggs to your total.
Common Mistake:
Many people get caught up in the number 5 and mistakenly add 5 eggs to their total, but they forget to question the logic behind the rooster laying eggs. Once you recognize the trick, you’ll realize this part doesn’t contribute to your egg count at all.
Putting It All Together: How Many Eggs Do You Have?
Let’s summarize the key points:
- You don’t start with 4 eggs because the riddle only suggested a hypothetical scenario.
- You do have 3 eggs because the thief gave them to you.
- You don’t get 5 eggs from the rooster because roosters can’t lay eggs.
So, after analyzing the riddle step by step, the correct answer is simple: You have 3 eggs, all thanks to the thief’s strange generosity.

The Power of Observation and Logical Thinking
This riddle isn’t just about counting—it’s about using logic and paying attention to the details. It teaches us that, sometimes, the obvious answer isn’t the right one. By slowing down, questioning assumptions, and analyzing each part of the riddle carefully, we can arrive at the correct conclusion.
Riddles like this one also highlight the importance of critical thinking. Being able to spot inconsistencies or misleading elements, like the mention of a rooster laying eggs, can make all the difference in solving puzzles and making decisions in everyday life.
Why Riddles Are Great for Your Mind
You might wonder, “Why spend time solving riddles?” Well, they’re more than just fun! Solving riddles is an excellent way to exercise your brain. They improve problem-solving skills, boost creativity, and enhance cognitive functions like memory and attention to detail. Plus, riddles often have multiple layers, teaching you how to approach a problem from different angles and find solutions.
So, the next time you come across a tricky riddle, don’t just rush to the answer. Take your time, think critically, and enjoy the challenge. Your brain will thank you for it!
Video : Popular Egg Math Problem
Challenge Yourself – Share Your Answer and Try More Riddles!
Now that you’ve solved the riddle, why not challenge your friends or family to solve it too? Share the riddle with them and see if they come up with the same answer. It’s always fun to see how others approach the problem and if they spot the same tricks along the way.
And remember, this riddle is just one example of how logical thinking can help you in many areas of life. Whether you’re solving puzzles, making decisions, or tackling challenges at work, the skills you build by practicing riddles can make a real difference.
If you enjoyed solving this riddle, don’t stop here! Keep exploring other logic puzzles and brain teasers to continue exercising your mind. And always remember—it’s not just about the answer, but the process of thinking through the problem that matters most.
Happy puzzling! Let us know your answers in the comments, and feel free to share any cool riddles you come across!