The controversy between Staten Island’s beloved Holtermann’s Bakery and Whoopi Goldberg has taken center stage, sparking a wave of reactions across New York City and beyond. Goldberg, co-host of The View, recently accused the family-owned bakery of refusing her a batch of Charlotte Russe desserts due to her political stance—a claim that Staten Island leaders and the bakery firmly deny. Let’s unravel the events, the fallout, and the overwhelming support for this 145-year-old Staten Island institution.
A False Claim Sparks Outrage
During a broadcast of The View, Whoopi Goldberg alleged that a Staten Island bakery declined to make her order for Charlotte Russe desserts because of her left-wing political beliefs. Without naming the bakery at the time, Goldberg stated, “They said their ovens had gone down, all kinds of stuff, but folks went and got them anyway… They did not like my politics.”
These remarks quickly ignited backlash, not just from the bakery but from Staten Island community leaders and residents. For a family business like Holtermann’s, which has served the community for over a century, such allegations weren’t just false—they were damaging.
The Truth Behind the Incident
Holtermann’s Bakery, a cherished institution in Staten Island, refuted Goldberg’s claims, citing a completely different reason for the failed order. The issue, they explained, stemmed from mechanical problems with their 60-year-old boiler, which temporarily affected production. Politics, they emphasized, had absolutely nothing to do with it.
Owner Jill Holtermann clarified that the bakery faced unexpected equipment failures on November 13, when Goldberg attempted to place her order for a birthday celebration. “We would never refuse service to anyone because of politics,” Holtermann explained. “We simply had mechanical issues.”
This explanation was supported by Staten Island Borough President Vito Fossella, who held a press conference outside the bakery to set the record straight. “This is one of the best families and businesses, not just in Staten Island, but in the country,” Fossella stated. “The people who defamed the Holtermann family should apologize… Not everybody wakes up every day and thinks about politics.”
A Surge of Support for Holtermann’s Bakery
In the wake of Goldberg’s controversial remarks, the Staten Island community—and even people across the country—rallied to support Holtermann’s Bakery. A continuous line of customers wrapped around the bakery, eager to show solidarity with the family business. The overwhelming support was not limited to Staten Island, as orders poured in from states as far away as Alabama and Tennessee.
Jill Holtermann described the response as both heartwarming and overwhelming. “I really am overwhelmed,” she told reporters. “Just to have people come out and talk and build up my business—it means so much.”
Many supporters went beyond purchasing baked goods. Customers donated donuts, sheet cakes, and cupcakes to local schools and first responders in an effort to show their appreciation for the bakery. From St. Peter’s Boys’ High School to public schools and firehouses, the goodwill was palpable.
Why the False Accusation Hit a Nerve
The backlash against Goldberg’s remarks goes deeper than one bakery. Staten Island has a tight-knit community that prides itself on supporting local businesses and standing up against perceived injustices. For many Staten Islanders, Goldberg’s comments felt like an unfair attack on a hardworking family and their legacy.
“Judging by the line today, I think the one simple message is: You don’t mess with Staten Island,” Fossella remarked during the press conference.
Goldberg’s remarks also reflect a broader frustration among many Americans over the increasing politicization of everyday life. The bakery’s supporters resonated with Fossella’s statement that “Not everybody wakes up every day and thinks about politics.” The sentiment is clear: small businesses should not become collateral damage in political debates.
Whoopi Goldberg’s Controversial Track Record
While Goldberg’s comments about Holtermann’s Bakery sparked immediate outrage, this isn’t the first time she has been accused of making inflammatory remarks. As a co-host of The View, Goldberg is known for her outspoken political views, particularly her disdain for former President Donald Trump.
In past episodes, Goldberg has made controversial statements, including claims that Trump would target interracial marriages. These remarks, often speculative and divisive, have contributed to her reputation as a polarizing figure in the media.
Critics argue that Goldberg’s platform on The View has become increasingly dominated by political rhetoric, sometimes at the expense of accuracy or nuance. The Staten Island bakery controversy adds another chapter to this ongoing debate about the role of media personalities in shaping public discourse.
The Fallout: Calls for an Apology
As the situation unfolds, Staten Island leaders and community members are demanding a public apology from Goldberg. They argue that her unfounded claims have unfairly defamed a beloved local business and misrepresented the truth.
Borough President Fossella was clear in his call for accountability. “Frankly, the people who defamed the Holtermann family should apologize,” he said during the press conference. For Staten Islanders, an apology would not only clear the bakery’s name but also send a message that baseless accusations carry consequences.
Holtermann’s Bakery, however, has chosen to focus on the outpouring of community support rather than dwelling on the controversy. Jill Holtermann expressed gratitude for the kindness shown by customers old and new, saying, “It’s been incredible to see how much love people have for our bakery.”
A Silver Lining for Holtermann’s Bakery
While the controversy may have started with false claims, it has ultimately shone a spotlight on Holtermann’s Bakery and the Staten Island community’s resilience. The surge in business, the generous donations, and the visible show of solidarity highlight the strength of local support systems.
For Holtermann’s, this moment is a reminder of the power of community. As customers continue to line up outside the bakery, one thing is clear: the Holtermann family and their business are here to stay.
Conclusion
The Holtermann’s Bakery controversy serves as a powerful lesson about the impact of words and the importance of accountability. Whoopi Goldberg’s false claims may have sparked outrage, but they also showcased the unwavering support of Staten Islanders and the broader public for a family-run business with deep roots in the community.
As the bakery continues to thrive, it’s a testament to the power of standing together in the face of adversity. This story reminds us all to think carefully before jumping to conclusions—and to always show love for our local businesses. After all, they’re more than just shops; they’re the heart of our communities.
